Tolkien Transactions XXVIII

August 2012

While July was a month of scouting (and a new job), August has, for me, very much been a Tolkien month. The climax was of course going to Loughborough for Return of the Ring 2012, but also the inevitable preparations as well as the aftermath of the conference have set its mark on the entire month.

This month it has suited my purposes to sort the contents under the following headlines:
1: News
2: Essays and Scholarship
3: The Return of the Ring
4: Reviews and Book News
5: Other Stuff
6: Rewarding Discussions
7: In Print
8: Web Sites
9: Sources

= = = = News = = = =

Runcorn and Widnes Weekly News, Thursday, 2 August 2012, ‘Halton libraries join Tolkien reading project’
http://www.runcornandwidnesweeklynews.co.uk/runcorn-widnes-news/runcorn-widnes-local-news/2012/08/02/halton-libraries-join-tolkien-reading-project-55368-31524268/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/cfmzpba
Actually the Reading Agency was looking for five reading groups to read The Hobbit in celebration of its 75th anniversary, but never mind :) This sounds great, and I hope that the five reading groups will do some interesting blogging on Tolkien's book.

Faine Greenwood, globalpost, Saturday, 11 August 2012, ‘"Hobbit’ pub sued by movie company, holds fundraiser"
http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/hollyworld/hobbit-pub-sued-movie-company-holds-fundraiser
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9kz235x
Hmm — if I said I was surprised, I wouldn't be telling the truth, exactly. Perhaps one should chip in, hoping to get the thing into court to see if Saul Zaentz' company really does have the rights to sue like this.

DB, Saturday, 11 August 2012, ‘slow news day’
http://kalimac.blogspot.com/2012/08/slow-news-day.html
Having missed the opportunity of announcing the contents of the next issue of Tolkien Studies, all David Bratman has to add this time is that the printed copies should be coming out soon (I'm still waiting for mine, though).

JDR, Monday, 13 August 2012, ‘I Talk to a Reporter’
http://sacnoths.blogspot.com/2012/08/i-talk-to-reporter.html
A seemingly well-prepared reporter has been speaking with John Rateliff — I am curious to see the final piece when it is released (no hints at the topic, but I suppose it's a fair guess that Tolkien and The Hobbit are at the heart of it . . .)

Jason Major, Universe Today, Tuesday, 14 August 2012, ‘"The Hobbit’ Author Gets a Crater on Mercury"
http://www.universetoday.com/96778/the-hobbit-author-gets-a-crater-on-mercury/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/d3cm995
So, if you should find yourself in the neighbourhood of Mercury, you might decide to pay the Tolkien crater a visit . . .

Max Eddy, International Science Times, Tuesday, 14 August 2012, ‘J.R.R. Tolkien Honored With A Crater on Mercury's North Pole’
http://www.isciencetimes.com/articles/3670/20120814/tolkien-crater-mercury.htm
http://preview.tinyurl.com/d6cncf8
This version of the story doesn't even mention the other eight artists acknowledged with Mercurian craters . . .

Owen Thomas, Business Insider, Monday, 20 August 2012, ‘Facebook Investor Peter Thiel Just Revealed What A Huge ‘Lord Of The Rings’ Fan He Is’
http://www.businessinsider.com/peter-thiel-tolkien-2012-8
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9y97843
The essence of the story is that Peter Thiel has used Tolkien-inspired names for a number of legal entities. My main reaction is to wonder how different our perceptions are — I thought something like ‘well, wouldn't we all?’ ;-)

Oxford Times, Thursday, 30 August 2012, ‘A feast of Hobbits at ready’
http://www.oxfordtimes.co.uk/leisure/9896402.A_feast_of_Hobbits_at_ready/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9e6r67k
About Oxonmoot — I wish I could go . . .

= = = = Essays and Scholarship = = = =

NMB, Wednesday, 1 August 2012, ‘Tolkien’s Icelandic Trolls’
http://nancymariebrown.blogspot.com/2012/08/tolkiens-icelandic-trolls.html
http://preview.tinyurl.com/btb6p34
A very nice piece on the possible Icelandic origin of the trolls in The Hobbit. If Arndis (an Icelandic au pair in the Tolkien family) had been telling the Tolkien children about these trolls, then Tolkien's statement in the book that his audience probably knows that trolls turn to stone if hit by sunlight is not all coy (as Rateliff finds), but rather a very reasonable expectation vis à vis his original audience. Also, I seem to recall this being a feature also of other trolls of Scandinavian folktales. This story is followed up by John Rateliff (see below for August 9th).

JM, Friday, 3 August 2012, ‘Tolkien's Metaphysics of the Music’
http://jonathansmcintosh.wordpress.com/category/j-r-r-tolkien/metaphysics-of-faerie/metaphysics-of-the-music/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8fkmw4k
This month takes us through a discussion of Platonic and Augustinian influences (in part 5), as well as Boëthius and Nietzsche, to discussions of what McIntosh sees as ‘misreadings’ of the Ainulindalë by earlier commenters (I certainly agree with him that the Music itself has no creative force), to the beginning of his own Thomistic reading (this month ending with part 14). Jonathan McIntosh seems determined to convince us of the pre-eminence of St. Thomas Aquinas as a philosophical source for Tolkien's work — I am convinced about St. Thomas being a source, but I am not sure that I can follow McIntosh with the pre-eminence. Still, I am learning a lot by following his blog, and I recommend it wholeheartedly.

Verlyn Flieger, LotR Plaza, Wednesday, 8 August 2012, ‘The Theorist of the Fairy-Tale’
http://www.lotrplaza.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=244405
An essay by Verlyn Flieger about Tolkien as a theorist of fairy-tales, both as expressed in his famous essay, ‘On Fairy-Stories’ and as expressed in his fiction. A must-read!!

H&S, Wednesday, 8 August 2012, ‘New Addenda and a Reply’
http://wayneandchristina.wordpress.com/2012/08/08/new-addenda-and-a-reply/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9xqh9fd
New addenda and corrigenda to several of their books, including a new page for The Art of the Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien — remember to pay attention to Wayne Hammond and Christina Scull's ‘Addenda and Corrigenda’ pages when you're using their books (this is an extraordinarily fine service that we should be very grateful for — also remember to advise Wayne and Christina when you find errors or omissions from their books, so that your findings can benefit the whole of the Tolkien community). The reply is to comments in the Mythprint review of The Art of the Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien.

JDR, Thursday, 9 August 2012, ‘An Icelandic au pair?’
http://sacnoths.blogspot.com/2012/08/an-icelandic-au-pair.html
John Rateliff's follow-up to Nancy Marie Brown's blog-post about ‘Tolkien's Icelandic Trolls’ (see above for August 1st). Rateliff adds some interesting comments about photos which corroborate Arndís' memories and Tolkien's knowledge about Icelandic troll stories, but overlooks, in my opinion, the importance of the knowledge of Tolkien's audience (relative to his own knowledge).

JDR, Friday, 10 August 2012, ‘More on Arndis Thorbjarnardottir’
http://sacnoths.blogspot.com/2012/08/more-on-arndis-thorbjarnardottir.html
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9xkavg3
Following up a bit more on the story about Arndís and her recollections about her stay as au pair in the Tolkien household.

JF, Friday, 10 August 2012, ‘Esgaroth — what’s in a name?’
http://lingwe.blogspot.com/2012/08/esgaroth-whats-in-name.html
Some speculations about the name ‘Esgaroth’ — be sure to also read the comments! I love this kind of word-games regardless of whether or not they are ‘correct’ in terms of the history of the word in Tolkien conscious or sub-conscious mind (I strongly suspect that it is not).

Talelmarhazad, Grey Havens Group, Thursday, 16 August 2012, "Tolkien's Mysterious ‘Shipwreck of Love"’
http://greyhavensgroup.com/2012/08/16/tolkiens-mysterious-shipwreck-of-love/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8e5g7gn
The idea that there is a something autobiographical about the love between Faramir and Éowyn is, of course, wholly speculative (and, since the analysis here points at another love interest than Edith, not likely to meet with the approval or help of the Tolkien Estate). I can't quite decide whether to merely reject the idea or to see it as at least a remote possibility.

BC, Monday, 20 August 2012, ‘Timing and causes of the breakdown of Tolkien and Lewis's close friendship and alliance’
http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.com/2012/08/timing-and-causes-of-breakdown-of.html
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8cnt6cv
I have said it before, and will probably need to say it again, but the reason I I like Dr. Bruce Charlton's blog so much, and recommend it so frequently, is not that I agree with everything he says, but because his posts usually make me think even when I, as is often the case, disagree — this, in my view, is a very valuable thing that helps me learn and grow. As the title says, this blog post discusses the whys and whens of the cooling of the friendship between C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien. I think the word ‘breakdown’ is probably an exaggeration both because it implies something more sudden than was the case, and because it suggests a more complete break than I think was the case. Of the arguments that Charlton put forth, I think he exaggerates the issues of Tolkien's health in the period he discusses — at least I read the Chronology for the years in question quite differently (there's the teeth, yes, but I see no indication of any kind of ‘psychological breakdown’). I do, however, not doubt that the other causes that Charlton mentions were important contributants to the cooling of the friendship between the two authors. He mentions Tolkien's reaction to The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (I have to say that I rather agree with Tolkien on that one), Tolkien's work on revising/editing LotR and The Silmarillion and getting them published.

Kelly Cowling, Friday, 24 August 2012, ‘Trio of One: Valentinian Soul Types in The Lord of the Rings’
http://greyhavensgroup.com/2012/08/24/trio-of-one-valentinian-soul-types-in-the-lord-of-the-rings/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9l2vyts
I'm afraid that I am running a little too late with my transactions to get through a long text of Jungian psychology and gnostic symbolism, neither of which are analytical frameworks for which I usually have much patience anyway. Still, the piece does look interesting, so I will certainly read it when I find the time.

Erin Heffernan, The Marquette Tribune, Thursday, 30 August 2012, ‘Frodo lives at Marquette with Tolkien course and lecture series’
http://marquettetribune.org/2012/08/30/marquee/frodo-lives-at-marquette-with-tolkien-course-and-lecture-series/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9mru37n
On a Tolkien course at the Marquette — where they can draw on their archives of Tolkien's drafts and manuscripts for The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings and Mr. Bliss.

JF, Friday, 31 August 2012, ‘Shadows of the past’
http://lingwe.blogspot.dk/2012/08/shadows-of-past.html
Out of the blissful waters of forgetfulness comes an interview with Daniel Grotta, author of the first book-length biography in English (generally considered to be very bad and full of factual errors). There's quite a bit to this post, including a link to a new issue of the Festival Journal (the journal associated with the Festival in the Shire).

= = = = The Return of the Ring = = = =

Demosthenes, Friday, 3 August 2012, ‘Return of the Ring hosting massive Tolkien art exhibit’
http://www.theonering.net/torwp/2012/08/03/60317-return-of-the-ring-hosting-massive-tolkien-art-exhibit/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9ucybsu
About the impressive array of Tolkien-inspired artists and artwork on exhibition at the Return of the Ring conference.

David Godsall, Loughborough Echo, Friday, 10 August 2012, ‘Lord of the Rings fans invited to JRR Tolkien conference at Uni’
http://www.loughboroughecho.net/news/loughborough-news/2012/08/10/lord-of-the-rings-fans-invited-to-jrr-tolkien-conference-at-uni-73871-31578082/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/95chgvv
The local news telling about the conference . . .

JD, Wednesday, 15 August 2012, ‘Loughborough Log: Day One’
http://goldseven.wordpress.com/2012/08/15/loughborough-log-day-one/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9zv7o6q
For most of us, this was day zero, the day before the day . . .
The following three posts by Jenny also deal with the Return of the Ring in Loughborough, and they are all very readable — you really, really should go read them!
Day two (16 August)
http://goldseven.wordpress.com/2012/08/16/loughborough-log-day-two/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8qzjw4e
Day three (17 August)
http://goldseven.wordpress.com/2012/08/17/loughborough-log-day-three/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8zuctny
Day four and five (20 August)
http://goldseven.wordpress.com/2012/08/20/loughborough-log-days-four-and-five/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9jy4flk

JV, Examiner, Thursday, 16 August 2012, ‘Return of the Ring conference opens with Tolkien art exhibit’
http://www.examiner.com/article/return-of-the-ring-conference-opens-with-tolkien-art-exhibit
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9nx7utn
A piece on the impressive art exhibition

AW, Thursday, 16 August 2012, ‘Loughborough’
http://wellinghall.livejournal.com/995893.html
More a comment on the town than on the conference.

John DiBartolo, Middle-earth News, Sunday, 19 August 2012, ‘Peter Jackson, Alan Lee, John Howe Greetings to the Tolkien Society From New Zealand’
http://news.mymiddleearth.com/2012/08/19/peter-jackson-alan-lee-john-howe-greetings-to-the-tolkien-society-from-new-zealand/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9ago5af
The video that was sent to the Return of the Ring.

JD, Monday, 20 August 2012, ‘Loughborough Pictures’
http://goldseven.wordpress.com/2012/08/20/loughborough-pictures/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8k57zn8
Pictures from the conference — this deserves to be mentioned separately (though unfortunately merely photographs, not Art by Dolfen).

BBC, Monday, 20 August 2012, ‘In pictures: Return of the Ring Festival’
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-19317810
Eight pictures from the Return of the Ring.

AW, Monday, 20 August 2012, ‘Loughborough’
http://wellinghall.livejournal.com/996275.html
This would be the very brief not of ‘I'm back’ :)

John DiBartolo, Middle-earth News, Friday, 24 August 2012, ‘Return of the Ring 2012 Wrap-up Interview’
http://news.mymiddleearth.com/2012/08/24/return-of-the-ring-2012-wrap-up-interview/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8vtbmmu
A nice video interview with deputy chair, Shaun Gunner.

TF, Saturday, 25 August 2012, ‘The Return of the Ring’
http://parmarkenta.blogspot.com/2012/08/ive-been-writing-about-return-of-ring.html
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8bc6vhk
My own report from the Return of the Ring.

Emil Johansson, Tuesday, 28 August 2012, ‘Return of the Ring 2012’
http://lotrproject.com/returnofthering/
Emil Johansson's pictures from the conference. Take me back, they do . . .

= = = = Reviews and Book News = = = =

Holly Ordway, Mythlore, Wednesday, 1 August 2012, ‘Mythopoeic Narnia’
http://www.mythsoc.org/reviews/mythopoeic-narnia-mythlore/
I really think that the final paragraph of Ordway's excellent review of the book by Salwa Khoddam says it all:
Probably the best way to look at Mythopoeic Narnia is
as the rough draft of a future book. The strengths of the
book are genuine, but remain largely conceptual; the
problems of the book are numerous and, in total, serious.
The problems could be addressed in an overhaul of the
book, but are more than sufficient to make it impossible
to recommend the book as currently published.

Sara Brown, Mythlore, Saturday, 3 August 2012, ‘Tolkien and Wales’
http://www.mythsoc.org/reviews/tolkien-wales/
Sara Brown wrote the Mythlore review of Carl Phelpstead's book on Tolkien and Wales, and it is reprinted here. Brown is overall positive despite pointing out a couple of weaknesses (I cannot agree with her comments regarding linguistic terms — I certainly have no linguistic training, but I found all such terms to be sufficiently explained in the text, including the ones she specifically mentions).

David Oberhelman, Mythopoeic Society, Sunday, 5 August 2012, ‘Mythopoeic Awards: 2012 Winners Announced’
http://www.mythsoc.org/news/award-winners-2012/
Announcing the 2012 winners of the Mythopoeic Awards. Of particular interest here is the winner of the award in Inklings Studies, Tolkien and Wales by Carl Phelpstead (see the Mythlore review elsewhere, as well as my review on Parma-kenta in August 2011). Congratulations to Carl and the other winners!

JDR, Saturday, 11 August 2012, ‘And the Winner Is . . .’
http://sacnoths.blogspot.com/2012/08/and-winner-is.html
Following up on the announcement of Carl Phelpstead winning the Mythopoeic Award in Inklings Studies . . .

Asbury University, Monday, 13 August 2012, ‘Asbury prof finishes book on ‘The Hobbit’ ahead of movie based on Tolkien classic’
http://www.kyforward.com/our-faith-and-values/2012/08/13/asbury-prof-finishes-book-on-the-hobbit-ahead-of-movie-based-on-tolkien-classic/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/btubf5k
More on the upcoming The Christian World of The Hobbit by Devin Brown and about the author (see also the interview with the Tolkien Library reported in the Transactions for May).

Various, the Mythopoeic Society, Monday, 20 August 2012, ‘Acceptance Remarks — 2012’
http://www.mythsoc.org/awards/2012/remarks/
The acceptance remarks from the winners of the 2012 Mythopoeic Awards.

PC, Tuesday, 21 August 2012, ‘Beyond Bree Calendar 2013: Evil in Middle-earth’
http://www.tolkienlibrary.com/press/1047-Beyond-Bree-Calendar-2013.php?513
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9otqkuf
About the 2013 Beyond Bree calendar.

PC, Sunday, 26 August 2012, ‘The fifth Beyond Bree Award was given to Mark T. Hooker’
http://www.tolkienlibrary.com/press/1048-Beyond-Bree-Award-V.php?514&utm_source=TolkienTransactions
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9j9j6qy
More information about the Beyond Bree Awards, about Mark T. Hooker (and his work on Tolkien) and on Beyond Bree.

Nancy-Lou Patterson, Mythlore, Wednesday, 29 August 2012, ‘How Thin is the Crust’
http://www.mythsoc.org/reviews/dark-tower-other-stories/
An old, 1979, very enthusiastic review of The Dark Tower and Other Stories by C.S. Lewis and edited by Walter Hooper.

Janet Brennan Croft, Mythlore, Friday, 31 August 2012, ‘Various Scholarly Journals’
http://www.mythsoc.org/reviews/various-scholarly-journals-2012/
Reviews of North Wind #29 (on George MacDonald), VII #28 (on the Inklings) and Tolkien Studies #8. A sober recounting of the contents of the various articles.

= = = = Other Stuff = = = =

JD, Wednesday, 1 August 2012, ‘Grand Old English Wash Brush or: Painting of Maglor’
http://goldseven.wordpress.com/2012/08/01/grand-old-english-wash-brush-or-painting-of-maglor/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9c5wn44
I'll readily admit that some of the technical stuff about the differences between various types of brushes, colours etc. is lost on me, but the thoughts that go into the picture are well worth reading, and the finished picture is amazing.

TF, Friday, 3 August 2012, ‘Glorfindel(s) I miss you!’
http://parmarkenta.blogspot.com/2012/08/glorfindels-i-miss-you.html
A reaction to Shaun Gunner's article in Amon Hen no. 236 with the same title. Shaun raises the question of where the great story-internal discussions have gone, and I follow up with some of my views on these discussions. In essence I think we ought to find some new topics for our great discussions, as Elven wings and Balrog Ears are difficult to take seriously now, whereas there are some very interesting story-internal discussions that could still be taken up (even if we cannot ultimately decide the ‘truth’ we may all learn something valuable in the process).

BC, Sunday, 5 August 2012, ‘The greatest mystery of C.S Lewis's life - is it so mysterious?’
http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.com/2012/08/the-greatest-mystery-of-cs-lewiss-life.html
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9rktpqh
Speculations on the nature and causes of C.S. Lewis' otherwise mysterious attachment to Mrs Janie Moore (‘Minto’). Bruce G. Charlton speculates that Lewis was servicing Mrs Moore as penance for a sexual relationship (before his becoming a Christian), and that this had a profound negative effect on C.S. Lewis' brother, Warnie. As I don't know much about Lewis at all, I can't really comment on these speculations.

Ivona Elenton, Grey Havens Group, Sunday, 5 August 2012, ‘The Kingdoms of Middle Earth in Sweden’
http://greyhavensgroup.com/2012/08/05/the-kingdoms-of-middle-earth-in-sweden/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9lxkq94
An account of at least four of the Tolkien Societies in Sweden.

Kelly Cowling, Grey Havens Group, Saturday, 11 August 2012, ‘On Feelings and Magic: Eliot, Williams and Tolkien’
http://greyhavensgroup.com/2012/08/11/on-feelings-and-magic-eliot-williams-and-tolkien/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8w5vq2h
From Eliot to Williams, to Kelly Cowling herself and with references to Tolkien. I wonder, however, if Cowling has spoken with trained scientists about this — if so, I will have to merely say that they have been trained in another scientific tradition than I. this post succeeds reasonably, I think, when it applies itself to analyse literature, but not so well when it applies itself to an analysis of human beings.

H&S, Monday, 13 August 2012, ‘Homeward Bound and Down to Earth’
http://wayneandchristina.wordpress.com/2012/08/13/homeward-bound-and-down-to-earth/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/bo76tdv
Christina Scull relates the last of the tale of Christina Scull and Wayne Hammond's trip to England, including their return to Williamstown, and the recent book additions (some of which have Tolkien connections).

JDR, Thursday, 16 August 2012, ‘"Modern America has virtually no use for the modern British children's book’ (What Hath Harry Wrought?)"
http://sacnoths.blogspot.com/2012/08/what-hath-harry-wrought.html
A bit of commentary on the comment (quoted in the title) by Humphrey Carpenter in 1985 — a mere decade before His Dark Materials and the Harry Potter series . . .

DB, Saturday, 18 August 2012, ‘another attempt at explaining the same ...’
http://kalimac.blogspot.com/2012/08/another-attempt-at-explaining-same.html
http://preview.tinyurl.com/c8tsxft
David Bratman has been caught up in a discussion and made some comments about Peter Jackson — I rather like David Bratman's way of saying things, and though I think that the Jackson trilogy are great as simple action-adventure films, I also do agree with Bratman on their status with respect to Tolkien's story.

BC, Tuesday, 21 August 2012, ‘Is there anything *like* Tolkien?’
http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.com/2012/08/is-there-anything-like-tolkien.html
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9zxkao8
No, there is not anything quite like Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings, is Charlton's conclusion, and I agree. It is, however, possible to list a number of works that share some similarities with Tolkien's grand work.

Don Burns, Sacramento Press, Thursday, 23 August 2012, ‘J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings series explored at Central Library programs’
http://www.sacramentopress.com/headline/72758/JRR_Tolkiens_Lord_of_the_Rings_series_explored_at_Central_Library_programs
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8dcadv2
Don't you just love when the title line says it all? All I have to add is that it is the Sacramento Public Library — if you're in the area, perhaps you should check out the details (though the timing will probably make it difficult for most people with a regular job).

JV, Friday, 24 August 2012, ‘Rivendell depicted in enormous LEGO diorama’
http://www.examiner.com/article/rivendell-depicted-enormous-lego-diorama
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9j4zwsb
Lego is amazing, and it's no surprise that they're making heaps of money! Now, how do I lobby for them to do a Tolkien-themed corner in Legoland (the original, of course - in Billund, Denmark) ;-)

APOD, NASA, Friday, 24 August 2012, ‘Moon Meets Morning Star’
http://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap120824.html
Ithil meets Eärendil . . . beautiful!

JD, Friday, 24 August 2012, ‘Messy Eärendil sketch’
http://goldseven.wordpress.com/2012/08/24/messy-earendil-sketch/
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9j82gt6
Another thing of, at least potential, beauty. So far, as Jenny Dolfen says, a ‘messy sketch’, but I agree that it would be very nice to have some more artwork featuring Eärendil, and I'll look forward to see what she may make of him in finished artwork.

JDR, Monday, 27 August 2012, ‘The New Arrival: Stella Mills' HROLF KRAKI’
http://sacnoths.blogspot.com/2012/08/the-new-arrival-stella-mills-hrolf-kraki.html
http://preview.tinyurl.com/8l2d733
On the saga of Hrolf Kraki and its relations to Tolkien's work.

Imogen Reed, Tolkien Library, Wednesday, 29 August 2012, ‘Fifteen Places Tolkien Fans should Visit before they Die’
http://www.tolkienlibrary.com/press/1053-fifteen-places-tolkien-fans-should-visit-before-they-die.php?519
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9vb39vr
I agree with most of what Imogen Reed lists here, though I have no use for New Zealand in a Tolkien context (I'd like to visit New Zealand, but that has nothing to do with my interest in Tolkien's work, to which the country has no connection at all). Since the countryside of the Somme has been restored over the past century, I wonder if anyone knows where one should go to get a feeling of the place that Tolkien experienced? Where does one go to get an impression of what life at the Somme front in 1917 was really like?

JDR, Friday, 31 August 2012, ‘hrolf kraki, con't’
http://sacnoths.blogspot.dk/2012/08/hrolf-kraki-cont.html
With some more about the edition of the Saga of Hrolf Kraki that Rateliff has got hold of: translated by Tolkien's student, Stella Mills, and this edition with a foreword by Priscilla Tolkien about the personal friendship between Stella Mills and the Tolkiens, but also the intriguing information that John Rateliff is ‘just starting to sketch out an article on JRRT and his lifelong support for women's higher education.’ I'll look forward to that one!

PC, Friday, 31 August 2012, ‘Tolkien Library Guest Post Guidelines’
http://www.tolkienlibrary.com/press/1054-tolkien-guest-post-guidelines.php?519
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9qtpd6d
Guidelines for those who would want to post a contribution to the Tolkien Library website.

= = = = Rewarding Discussions = = = =

‘Glorfindel(s), I miss you!’
news:a81hq0FediU1@mid.individual.net
https://groups.google.com/d/topic/rec.arts.books.tolkien/GRhKLBMwL-8/discussion
http://preview.tinyurl.com/9dzzezv
Based on Shaun Gunner's article in Amon Hen 236, we had a good discussion of why the great story-internal debates have petered out without being replaced by new debates.

‘Northhalde Tré and the Evil North’
http://www.lotrplaza.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=244322
Though much of the good stuff was posted in July, I didn't really notice this thread until August. The topic is medieval inspirations for locating the fortress of evil (Utumno and Angband in Tolkien's works) in the north.

‘The nature of the three elven rings’
http://www.lotrplaza.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=244132
A discussion of the Three Rings that sort of drifts into other aspects, such as the nature of the invisibility effect of the other Rings of Power and such.

= = = = In Print = = = =

Beyond Bree August 2012
This issue opens with a long review of Christopher MacLachlan's Tolkien and Wagner: The Ring and Der Ring by Jim Allan, who doesn't like the book very much, finding that while it ‘is not without value in places’ it generally displays a large confirmation bias to the point of making its author appear gullible. Beyond Bree continues with a review of a book owned by the Tolkien children, The Starry Heavens from 1933, news about The Hobbit films and merchandise, and a review of a trailer for the Hobbit film. Mark Hooker (winner of the fifth Beyond Bree Award — see above) backs up a claim of additional knowledge to add to a Mythlore article on the origins of the word ‘Hobbit’ in the first of a series (this time on the artillery piece ‘a hobit’), and Dale Nelson continues his series on the ‘Days of the Craze’ with an article on ‘Henry Resnik on Tolkien and Tolkien Fandom’. The newsletter is rounded off by the usual letters, references, notices and finally a couple of original poems by Geoff Davies (Last of the Ring Bearers) and Matthew Amish (Distant Shores are Calling).

Mythprint vol.49 no.6/7, August 2012, whole no. 361
This issue of Mythprint is filled with four reports from this year's Mythcon, which again seems to have been an enjoyable affair. In addition to the Mythcon reports, there is a review of the comic-book biography of Tolkien by Marcel Aubron-Bülles, who finds that the book, unsurprisingly, doesn't offer anything to a serious Tolkienist, but also that it ‘might be a good and easy read’ for young people with an awakening interest in the man behind the tale.

= = = = Web Sites = = = =

Artwork, Illustrations and Sketches by Jenny Dolfen
http://goldseven.wordpress.com/
Jenny Dolfen's (remember that she's German — the "J" is pronounced roughly as the consonant sound of English "Y") Tolkien-inspired art is wonderful! I shan't be linking to every sketch (though probably to every finished work) that she posts, but go check out her work for yourself.

The Tolkienist
http://thetolkienist.com
Blog by Tolkienist Marcel R. Aubron-Bülles — hopefully he will soon have something to post there rather than just the announcement that something is coming . . . (c'mon, Marcel!)

J.R.R. Tolkien's ‘The Lord of the Rings’ and the Scottish Border
http://server13.web-mania.com/users/northeah/index.htm
A web-site by Christine Ahmed looking into connections between Tolkien's book and the Scottish Border. Interesting material enough for long study here.

José Manuel Ferrández Bru
http://www.josemanuelferrandez.com/
The website of Tolkien scholar José Manuel Ferrández Bru, who has studied particularly the influence of Tolkien's guardian, Fr. Francis Morgan. So far the website is in Spanish only, but I'm hoping that it will appear in English soon (it promises so, but how soon is 'soon'?)

= = = = Sources = = = =

John D. Rateliff (JDR) — ‘Sacnoth's Scriptorium’
http://sacnoths.blogspot.com

Jason Fisher (JF) — ‘Lingwë — Musings of a Fish’
http://lingwe.blogspot.com

Michael Drout (MD) — ‘Wormtalk and Slugspeak’
http://wormtalk.blogspot.com/

Wayne G. Hammond & Christina Scull (H&S) — ‘Too Many Books and Never Enough’
http://wayneandchristina.wordpress.com/

Pieter Collier (PC) — ‘The Tolkien Library’
http://www.tolkienlibrary.com/

Douglas A. Anderson (DAA) et Al. — ‘Wormwoodiana’
http://wormwoodiana.blogspot.com

Corey Olsen (CO), ‘The Tolkien Professor’
http://www.tolkienprofessor.com

David Bratman (DB), ‘Kalimac’
http://kalimac.blogspot.com/
and the old home:
http://calimac.livejournal.com/

Larry Swain (LS), ‘The Ruminate’
http://theruminate.blogspot.com

Andrew Wells (AW), ‘Musings of an Aging Fan’
http://wellinghall.livejournal.com

Various, ‘The Northeast Tolkien Society’ (NETS), ‘Heren Istarion’
http://herenistarionnets.blogspot.com

Bruce Charlton (BC), ‘Tolkien's The Notion Club Papers’
http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.com/

Marcel R. Aubron-Bülles (MB), ‘The Tolkienist’
http://thetolkienist.com/

Andrew Higgins (AH), ‘Wotan's Musings’
http://wotanselvishmusings.blogspot.com

Various, The Mythopoeic Society
http://www.mythsoc.org

Henry Gee (HG) ‘cromercrox’, ‘The End of the Pier Show’
http://occamstypewriter.org/cromercrox/

Jonathan S. McIntosh (JM), ‘The Flame Imperishable’
http://jonathansmcintosh.wordpress.com/

Morgan Thomsen (MT), ‘Mythoi’
http://mythoi.tolkienindex.net

Steuard Jensen (SJ), ‘Strings, Rings, and Other Things’
http://steuard.livejournal.com

John Howe (JH)
http://www.john-howe.com

Jenny Dolfen (JD)
http://goldseven.wordpress.com/

Nancy Marie Brown (NMB), ‘God of Wednesday’
http://nancymariebrown.blogspot.com

Josh Vogt (JV), ‘Tolkien Examiner’
http://www.examiner.com/tolkien-in-national/josh-vogt

David Simmons (DS), ‘Aiya Ilúvatar’
http://www.aiyailuvatar.org/

Michael Martinez (MM), ‘Tolkien Studies Blog’
http://blog.tolkien-studies.com/

Michael Martinez (MM), ‘Middle-earth’
http://middle-earth.xenite.org/

Troels Forchhammer (TF), ‘Parmar-kenta’
http://parmarkenta.blogspot.com

Mythprint — ‘The Monthly Bulletin of the Mythopoeic Society’
http://www.mythsoc.org

Amon Hen — the Bulletin of the Tolkien Society
http://www.tolkiensociety.org/

Beyond Bree — the newsletter of the Tolkien Special Interest Group of the Americal Mensa
http://www.cep.unt.edu/bree.html

- and others

The Return of the Ring

I've been writing about The Return of the Ring at the LotR Plaza and the Tolkien usenet newsgroups, and I thought I'd share my report here as well.

Thursday

Thursday was arrival day, which of course gave a bit of extra hassle. I had found that renting a car at Heathrow would not be much more expensive than taking the train, but on arriving I found that I had to part the car a goodly way from accommodations and the events of the conference. Still, I checked in to a student room and got myself ready to four days in something close to a Tolkien geek's idea of paradise.

At the gatherings of the whole event, it was obvious that many people know each other from countless Oxonmoots and what-have-you in the Tolkien Society, but there was also a significant amount of 'good to finally meet you in the flesh' going on between people who have interacted — sometimes for a very long time — on the internet.

There were two lecture sessions yesterday, and for the first session I had chosen to go to a couple of talks on 'Philosophy and Ethics . First up was a professor from an American university, Laura Miller-Purrenhage, ‘Teaching Leadership and Ethics through Tolkien’, who spoke on how she had constructed a course on Tolkien by focusing on creating objectives in the subjects leadership and ethics. It was an interesting approach to a literature class (one often gets the impression that ‘reading Tolkien’ would be the normal answer to the objective of a Tolkien class). Fortunately the subject on how to construct a good course on Tolkien's work becomes more and more relevant to more and more people, but I will admit that I had a hard time relating to a number of the problems and issues that she was talking about — a result of never having been in her situation, nor being likely ever to do so.

The second speaker was Franco Manni from Italy who spoke on ‘Tolkien versus the History of Philosophy’ how Tolkien related to a list of specific philosophers starting with Plato and ending with a number of twentieth century relativist philosophers. The paper was very interesting and engaging, and Franco Manni spoke with an obvious passion for his subject. To put it very shortly, Manni's thesis was that Tolkien reacted positively to (parts of the works of) most ancient and medieval philosophers, Plato, Aristotle, Augustine, Boëthius, Aquinas. Tolkien also, according to Manni, reacted to some of the nineteenth century romantic philosophers, but only indirectly as these philosophers reached him by the way of the great philologists. Finally Manni found that Tolkien mostly ignored most twentieth century philosophers, having no use for their ideas.

After a short break the second round of sessions was due. For that I had chosen a session on ‘Tolkien's Sources’. The first speaker, Allen Jenkins, ran a comparitive study between Tolkien and the native American authoer, Sherman Alexi titled ‘Of Elves and Indians: The Aboriginal Outsider’. He drew up a number of interesting parallels, in particular between the situations of Tolkiens' Elves and the reservation Indians in Sherman Alexi's books, and he believed that the idea of peoples under threat (Tolkien's Elves under threat from the Age of Man) was the common denominator that brought them together.

The rest of this session was an hour-long panel on Tolkien and ‘Source Criticism’. Chaired by Verlyn Flieger and with participation from Tom Shippey, Mark Atherton, Renée Vink and Alex Lewis, this was a lively panel with a good interaction with the audience and discussions covered many interesting corners. Tom Shippey crying out that ‘Authors lie!’ and telling us in no uncertain terms that Tolkien did so too is a memory that stands out, but it was certainly not the only memorable point that was made. In the end it was proposed that source criticism is one of the tools we have to try to understand the mental landscape in which Tolkien's stories grew, and I think I can subscribe to that as a worthwhile endeavour (more than trying to show where Tolkien got his ideas from or ‘how he worked’).

Exhibition & Dealers' Room
Photo: Andrew Wells

In the late afternoon there was an opening ceremony with various dignataries appear, two of them appearing in a video: Alan Lee and John Howe sent a video greeting, though most of the talking was being done by some short bloke from New Zealand. In the evening we had an opening party, which was mostly a good excuse for some socializing, where I ended up having some very intersting discussions with Shaun Gunner, Emil Johansson and Marcel Aubron-Bülles.

Friday

Friday dawned brightly . . . I'm sure, though I cannot really say as I was still in bed at the time.

Having got to bed after midnight, I decided to do breakfast late and then go to the first session, but a minor confusion about the location of the breakfast venue meant that I skipped breakfast.

My first session today was with Alex Lewis and titled ‘The Lost Arthur’. Alex Lewis is writing a book on Arthurian influences on Tolkien, and made a rather intersting point by saying that the unpublished (for almost a year more) The Fall of Arthur acted as a filter through which the matter of Britain influenced Tolkien's Middle-earth writings. To some extent this plays into John Rateliff's idea of Tolkien borrowing from himself more than anything else — from the Arthuriana to Tolkien's Fall of Arthur and from there to Middle-earth. Another essential point that Lewis made in his presentation was about viewing these source studies (or the game of what influences what — actually Lewis was talking about how Tolkien's texts influenced each other) as caleidoscopic: each perspective adds to our understanding, but none of them is the complete picture. All in all it was an enjoyable presentation, though I think Lewis fired his best shots in the beginning (defining LotR as ‘mythic history’ and talking about the ‘Tolkien Conundrum’ — that much of Tolkien's writings were unfinished, that they were very much in flux and even the published writings cannot be considered as Tolkien's last thought on the matter).

In the second time slot, I went to a session titled ‘Biography’. The first speaker was José Manuel Ferrández Bru who gave a talk titled ‘J.R.R. Tolkien's second father: Fr. Francis Morgan and other non-canonical influences.’ For the most part this talk covered some of the same ground as Bru's article in Tolkien Studies VIII, but this time with the addition of illustrations which at some points brought Bru's points out better than the article (pictures of letters, for instance). This time round, I was also more intrigued by Bru's suggestion that the inspiration for the wind-riddle in The Hobbit should be sought in a Spanish poem by one of Fr. Francis' family members, which stood in Fr. Francis' library. Towards the end, Bru suggested, half-jokingly I think, that there might be some echoes of Fr. Francis' influence on Tolkien in some specifics of Tolkien's fiction — apart from the wind-riddle, the Barrels out of Bound chapter might reflect also Fr. Francis' family's involvement with the sherry business, Minas Tirith may derive some qualities from a Spanish town (white houses, mountainous location), and the scouring of the Shire may owe something to the Spanish casting out Napoleon.

Bru was followed by Colin Duriez who spoke on ‘The origins of the Inklings.’ Some of the things that I took away from this was related to specifics of the history of the Inklings: when were they meeting in what way, the differences between the reading-sessions in (mostly) C.S. Lewis' room in Magdalen and the pub-meetings, the informal and unstructured nature of the club and the centrality of C.S. Lewis.

Charlie Ross
Photo: Andrew Wells

After a lunch cut short, most of us worked our way to the Barrow Hall to experience Charlie Ross perform his ‘One-man Lord of the Rings’. The show is based on Jackson's film trilogy, but it is still very funny and he adds a number of references to the book (I shan't say if performing before an audience of which half were in costume at a Tolkien Society event made him add a few extra book-references). Unfortunately I was rather tired and suffering from a headache (and the sound was very loud), so there were a number of jokes that went past me witout me noticing (not until everybody else were laughing, which is always a bit too late ...). Memorable moments include the attempt to read the Elvish script on the One Ring (“One for the money, two for the show, three for . . . no, wait, Elvish script, you say? One Ring to rule them all . . .”) and Gimli at the Council of Elrond promising Frodo his beard (“Because I broke me bloody axe”) and Legolas announcing “You have my hair!” Overall I am glad that I got the chance to see this show.

Taking a short break to lie down for half an hour made a big difference for my readiness for the video of Tom Shippey's talk at the 6th Lustrum, ‘The Ancestors of Hobbits - strange creatures from English Folklore’. At this event Tom Shippey spoke about a number of the creatures mentioned in the Denham Tracts, explaining what is known about them etc. The main point was to highlight that the Denham Tracts carries a suggestion of what he called ‘the lost world of English folklore’ — the indication that the lower mythology of England had not always been the poor and watered-down affair that the folklorist found once they finally got round to write things down: the hint of a much richer English folklore hiding just a few hundred years before the texts were written down.

Tom Shippey lecturing
Photo: Andrew Wells

The real treat of the day was the live talk by Tom Shippey on ‘Tolkien on Leadership’. I had never before seen Tom Shippey live, though of course various reports and video clips have filtered down, but he really is a fantastic lecturer (and an entertainer as well), capable of captivating his audience completely. Shippey thought that Tolkien appears not to have thought much about leadership as such before The Lord of the Rings (claiming that the leaders shown in the earlier works are actually quite bad leaders). Then he looked at leaders in LotR and grouped them in six categories with one or two examples in each: the sacrificial leader (Théoden), the suicidal leader (Denethor), the persuasive leader (Saruman), the counsellor leader (Elrond & Galadriel), the loyal leader (Faramir — loyalty here mainly meaning upwards), and the ideal leader (Aragorn). The Orkish leader, Uglúk, with his order-keeping abilities was also noted and duly admired. Shippey found that Tolkien's position on leadership could be summed up in three pieces of advice: 1) be visible 2) don't publishise yourself too much to others, and 3) any decision is better than no decision. Shippey admits to not being an expert on leadership, and I think that more work could be done in this topic (some has already been done by a Finnish scholar of business management, though only in Finnish), but I would agree with Shippey that these three seem to be important elements in Tolkien's portrayal of a good leader.

In the post-talk discussions, I managed to get a little better insight into Shippey's dissatisfaction with Tolkien's analysis of Maldon — my problem being that we have in current use in Denmark the word overmod which has a meaning very close to that which Tolkien assigns to O.E. ofermod in his treatment of the Maldon (‘The Homecoming of Beorhtnoth Beorthelm's Son’ and the related essay ‘ofermod’). Possibly because I was managing to look very fan-boyish, I was very kindly invited to share a beer with Shippey and Ronald Hutton before dinner.

Saturday

Friday was the day where I went to bed three times — the first time shortly after midnight and the last time about 11PM. The result is that I approached Saturday feeling considerably more sprightly than Friday, which was certainly a good thing. However, after this I got rather busy, so you'll hopefully forgive me for not continuing the tale until now, when I have returned to that spot of Middle-earth that I call home.

In the first time-slot, I went to a session on the Ainulindalë. This was lead off by Peter Gilliver (one of the authors of The Ring of Words), who spoke on ‘Making the Music, a possible source for the Ainulindalë.’ The premise of this talk was a very striking correspondence in both imagery and wording in Gerald Manley Hopkins' ‘notes on Ignatius Loyola's Spiritual Exercises’ to imagery and phrasing in Tolkien's Ainulindalë. However, though written in 1881, these notes remained unpublished until 1937, far too late for them to have influenced imagery and phrases in The Book of Lost Tales, and while possible connections could be made, these were all much too tenuous for anyone to assert a source. Gilliver had then looked at other texts containing the image of a creator having angels sing for him and a musical rebellion leading to a fall of angels, and had found two cases (one of these an interesting Babylonian text), but ultimately the consensus was that it seemed more likely that there was a general idea floating about in the Oxford Catholic circles (in 1919 there were about 100 Catholic students in Oxford) regarding a musical interpretation of the rebellion of (some of) the angels.

After this came Reuven Naveh who spoke on ‘The Ainulindale and Tolkien's Approach to Modernity.’ Naveh suggested that the descriptions of the Discord of Morgoth are consistent with early receptions of atonal music emphasizing dissonance. While Naveh used Arnold Schönberg as his example, this was not because he felt that Tolkien's words' necessarily were a reaction to Schönberg in particular, but to his ‘type of music’ more generally. This took Naveh on to Tolkien's general reaction against modernism, of which Naveh perceived a strong rejection by Tolkien. One of the interesting points that Naveh made was that Tolkien seemed to have been rooted in tonal music and it's emphasis on harmony that even Wagner's play with a greater element of dissonance (though still within context of tonal music) may have felt, to Tolkien, for that very reason, ugly and incomprehensible.

At this point, I took a break, so that the next couple of time-slots were kept empty. I did, however, have a nice chat with David Doughan (whom I've met on-line), who had also attended the morning session on the Ainulindalë and who had some very interesting further comments on the musical talk (David clearly being far more knowledgeable than I about what might broadly be termed ‘classical music’). Also I took the time to enjoy the exhibition of Tolkien-inspired artwork. There was an impressive list of artists who exhibited their work at the conference, and while I do not as a rule get the vivid images while reading that I understand many do (and I believe Tolkien did), I can certainly enjoy good art. I found something enjoyable in nearly all of the artists works, and for a few of the artists, I found most of their work enjoyable (no one mentioned, and thus none forgotten), though even among these well-loved artists, the all-pervasive imagery of the Jackson films could not be wholly escaped: there was a blue Galadriel that seemed to me inspired more by Jackson's vision than by Tolkie's words, just as there were more than one depiction of Viggo Mortensen (who is, I am sure, a very nice man who deserves every portrait) that claimed to depict Aragorn / King Elessar. The dealers' stalls were dangerous waters for me — the temptation to over-spend on the many interesting books there was great, and perhaps I should be grateful that the Tolkien Society Trading's stall only had two different volumes of Tolkien Studies on their ‘½ price’ shelves (none of which I had — the past tense being important here . . . )

David Doughan
Photo: Andrew Wells

In the last of the day's multi-track time-slots, I went to a session on The Notion Club Papers, which should be found in an Oxford bin this year (I wonder if some faithful Tolkienists have been trawling the colleges' waste bins this summer?). First up was David Doughan speaking simply about ‘The Notion Club.’ The aim of the talk seemed make people interested in this piece of Tolkien's writings and make them think about it. To that end Doughan had picked a series of interesting facts about the Notion Club Papers, including the identity game (matching aspects of the fictional club members to aspects of the members of the Inklings), a history of the idea of time-travelling through dreams and visions and (especially) the connections to the linguistic work, The Drowning of Anadûne, and The Lord of the Rings.

The second presentation of this session was ‘From 2012 to Atlantis and back again. Tolkien's Time-Travelling and the Notion Club Papers Mystery’ by Xavier de la Huerga. Weaving a thread through Tolkien's Notion Club Papers, ideas of (biologically) inherited memory, Mayarin calendars and meteorological phenomena, de la Huerga gave me the impression that he wanted me to believe in some kind of mysticism (though he didn't exactly say it in that many words), and as a physicist I have to admit that I resented this feeling, and though it is possibly completely unintended, possibly a complete misunderstanding on my part, it did prevent me from connecting to the presentation as I would normally do.

From the Notion Club session, we hurried on to hear Verlyn Flieger speak in the big auditorium where Tom Shippey had entertained on Friday. Verlyn Flieger didn't entertain (though she did use humour), but instead she provoked: her talk on ‘Tolkien's French Connection’ was thought-provoking in the very best sense of the word, and despite a very different lecturing style from Tom Shippey, she had the audience every bit as much in thrall as he. Starting out from Tolkien's use of the French words aventures and quest in his essay ‘On Fairy-Stories’, Flieger took us through the magical forest of Broceliande, where Knights Errant went for simple aventures (as recounted e.g. by Chrétien de Troyes) and to the noble nights in Le Morte d'Arthur of which some (like Gawain) went on aventures while others went on quests. These she compared convincingly to Bilbo's [u]adventures[/u] (teaching us to say the word with her as she read all the, IIRC, eleven occurrences of the word in the description of the first day (Tuesday) in The Hobbit ). Though it is not repeated as many times, Frodo's story is clearly about a quest, and Flieger showed how the distinction and the two types of stories were tied up with a French romance tradition.

Torchlight procession
Photo: Lindon

After an enjoyable evening with more friends, new and old, it was time for first the Masquerade. Unfortunately the day was so hot and the room so packed that I couldn't stand it, and so I ended up outside, sharing the beer I had brought from Denmark. It was originally bought for Jason Fisher, when I thought he was coming, but I thought I'd bring it anyway. The beer was Bøgebryg from the brewery Skovlyst, and the name of the brew translates to ‘beech brew’. The beech has also given us the words book = bog (Danish) = Buch (German), because the habit of inscribing runes on staves of beech. From there we also, in German and Danish have our ‘beech-staves’, die Buchstaben, bogstaver, which are our names for the letters. So in a way I was bringing ‘book-beer’ to a Tolkien Conference, which seemed highly appropriate, and I was very pleased that both beer and pun were well received. The Masquerade, and hence our pun-beering, ended with a torchlight procession, which featured a distinct lack of something — either some pitchforks and a monster (and a barn to torch), or some ships to burn (so we could prevent that self-important usurper from following! Helcaraxë take him!)

The last item on the Saturday agenda was the auction. In addition to various donations from attendees and others (including four boxes of the ‘Mines of Moria’ Lego set and some wonderful artwork by attending artists), there were a lot of old fanzines on auction. This being because the Tolkien Society has closed it's lending library and now only maintains an archive (from which members can get photocopies of articles for their research), so they were selling out of their doubles (or triples or whatever). The words in The Hobbit about the prices at auctions applies here, with early issues of obscure smial journals fetching several tens of pounds. I got myself a Mallorn 43 and a Mythlore 12 for a total of £6.50 — mostly for the fun of being a part of it. And it certainly was great fun.

Sunday

My presentation
Photo: Lindon

I got up a little late on Sunday (skipping breakfast) so as to get as much sleep as possible (the action had ended not long before 1 AM) before it was time for my own fifteen minutes (or rather thirty) in the spotlight. Having had my paper printed, I sat down to read it through critically for the first time, ending up with an insane amount of corrections, additions and deletions to keep track of, but in the end I think I got through reasonably well (i.e. without loosing my thread more than a couple of times). My paper, ‘"in the memory of old wives" - Old Tales and Fairy-stories in Middle-earth’ was based on the idea that Tolkien not only constructed The Lord of the Rings to be a highly successful fairy-story according to the principles he laid out in his essay ‘On Fairy-Stories,’ but that he also exemplifies several of his points by letting his characters experience the effects of metafictional fairy-stories.

I was followed by Maureen Mann, to whom I had afterwards to apologize, because it took me the first ten minutes of her presentation to get back to the here and now, and when I finally caught up with the thread of her talk on ‘"various queer things": The House of Tom Bombadil and Fairie,’ I realized that it was highly interesting, and that it took up very excellently where I had left off (had the programming been reversed, I would have just as smoothly taken up the thread where she had left it). Maureen Mann dealt with one episode from The Lord of the Rings that I had left out: Tom Bombadil's power of narrative enchantment, which she discussed in depth and in further context. Where I had merely skated the surface, barely scratching it, in my presentation of an overarching idea, Maureen Mann expertly drilled through the ice in one spot and drew from there crystal-clear waters. After getting back home I have been mailing with Maureen, and will very much enjoy getting to read her paper in my own time.

The last spot in our session was a talk about ‘Tolkien's Faerian Drama: Origins and Valedictions’ by Janet Brennan Croft. This took up the idea of the dream-vision as an example of Faërian drama, the enchantment Tolkien describes in ‘On Fairy-Stories,’ and investigated this topic with examples from other authors as well as from Tolkien. I very much enjoyed the presentation, particularly the attempt to extract some common characteristics of a Faërian Drama Dream-vision (which includes the meeting, the intersection, of aesthetic and ethic) based on examples ranging from medieval stories (such as Pearl) via Dickens to Tolkien. Going through my notes and writing up these comments, I come to wonder how she deals with Tolkien's rejection of dream-stories as proper fairy-stories (I can see at least a couple of possible routes, none of which might be the one that Croft would choose).

After lunch I went to another session on ‘Tolkien's Sources’, starting with Yoko Hemmi who spoke on ‘Tolkienesque Transformations: Post-Celticism and Possessiveness in ‘The Lay of Aotrou and Itroun’.’ The paper (at least as it seemed to me) had two main theses. One was the idea of ‘post-celticism,’ which, as I understood it, is created by adding ‘the fair elusive beauty that some call Celtic (though it is rarely found in genuine ancient Celtic things)’ (Letters, no. 131) to the authentically celticism of the ancient Breton lays, and the other was that Tolkien, in his Lay of Aotrou and Itroun also added possessiveness as a moral flaw (the following discussion also suggested a connection of possessiveness and the desire for immortality). The presentation as a whole followed very well on to Verlyn Flieger's presentation on Saturday, though I am afraid that this somewhat bland summary doesn't do it justice.

Next up was Gerard Hynes with a presentation that fell directly within one of the areas of Tolkien studies that I am very interested in. Speaking of ‘Tolkien’s Boethius, Alfred’s Boethius,’ Gerard Hynes argued that the changes made to the text in the Old English translation of Boëthius' Consolation of Prophecy attributed to King Alfred (Hynes called it a re-interpretation rather than merely a translation) makes the translated text a more likely source for Tolkien than the original Latin. Summarising Hynes' summary of the relevant differences, Alfred's version loosens causality, allowing a greater option for changing providence — the Latin version deals with the freedom to think, the Old English version with the freedom to act. Thinking of this presentation afterwards, this summary seems to me to match nearly perfectly the differences in the operation of free will between Men and Elves in Tolkien's world (as described by Verlyn Flieger, Charles Noad and myself — you have no idea what pleasure it gave me to write this comment :-) ): Elves following the model of the Latin Boëthius and Men following the model of the Old English Alfredian Boëthius. Such a model would seem also strangely appropriate in other ways (which is probably why I am at once attracted to it and reluctant to adopt it).

The last presention of this session on sources took moved the focus a few centuries forward to discuss ‘Tolkien and Romanticism.’ The basic idea of Anna Thayer (née Slack) was to place Tolkien in a Romantic tradition, though not quite as radical as the original romanticists, and I think the idea went down quite well. It does certainly seem straightforward that Tolkien incorporates a number of ideas / themes / images adopted from romanticism, though I would probably be more cautious about calling Tolkien a romanticist as such (a claim, it must be emphasised, that Anna Thayer did not make!). Ending with the image of the piercing beauty, and the consolation gained from the untouchability and eternalness of Sam's sighting of a star while in Mordor closed the loop nicely to several other presentations (including my own) touching on Tolkien's idea of Faërie.


The last of the day's multi-track sessions, I spent with a panel on ‘Tolkien Research’ chaired by Janet Brennan Croft (editor of Mythlore) and including Verlyn Flieger, Bob Blackham, John Garth, and Angie Gardner (note that only one of these was a university professor doing academic research on Tolkien). There were several very positive and inspiring things to get from this panel: it is possible to access most of the things if you have a good reason (and someone to recommend you in the case of the Bodleian), the exceptions being all the Silmarillion papers and the private papers (both in the Bodleian) that are controlled by the Estate. Part of what I took away from this panel is a list of libraries featuring important archives of Tolkieniana, including what they contain and how to get into them (though ‘present myself’ at the Marquette might present a bit of an obstacle, but only due to it being in Wisconsin, USA and my living in Denmark). Overall I found the session informative, inspiring and encouraging — what more can one hope for in a session focusing on the possibility for contributing to Tolkien studies by independent researchers and scholars.

Nancy Martsch
Photo: Andrew Wells

Actually the above wasn't really the last of the multi-track events. Just before dinner we had to choose again — this time between Nancy Martsch's ‘Thirty Years of Tolkien Fandom’ and the Christine Davidson Memorial Lecture, given by Ben Barootes titled ‘These Fading Days: Language, Loss, and Recovery in Tolkien's Legendarium.’ This was a tough choice, but I ended up listening to Ben Barootes, whom I had talked with over dinner one day (I had also spoken with Nancy Martsch, and I would have loved to hear her talk).

Ben Barootes, Christine Davidson Memorial Lecture
Photo: Lindon

I am not sure that I could do justice to Ben's presentation (there is a good reason why he won the award that was set up to let a promising young Tolkien scholar participate in the Return of the Ring conference and give this lecture). He took his outset in the narrator's comments on Frodo's vain attempt command the Ringwraiths at the Ford of Bruinen to go back to Mordor, ‘but Frodo had not the power of Bombadil,’ and then asked why? The answer to this question should, according to Ben Barootes, be found in Northrop Frye's model of evolution of language in three phases (see The Phases and Modes of Language). Ben Barootes wove, with great eloquence, ideas concerning language, word- and name-magic (and song-magic), ‘the long defeat’ and other ideas together to a tapestry of compelling force, and though I am not sure that I can walk the whole nine yards with Ben, I'll be there with him for the seven or eight of them, and I am impressed with the explanatory power of his model.

The final point on the agenda before the grand Banquet also covered thirty years with a relation with Tolkien's work. Having to call my wife (Sunday was, after all, her birthday), I missed the start, but still got to hear most of Brian ‘Sibley in Middle-earth: A Thirty-Year Ramble.’ Full of entertaining anecdotes, this ‘ramble’ (let's honour Brian Sibley by keeping his own name for it) also proved thought-provokingly interesting for me as a firm book-lover (who put any adaptation far below the original, and any narrative adaptation even lower . . .) — I have certainly learned a greater respect for adapting artists (regardless of whether or not I like their adaptation as an adaption).

Troels (me) at the banquet
Photo: Lindon

After hearing Brian Sibley, I had to rush back to my room to change for the banquet. Fortunately it was little delayed, so I was still in good time to enjoy the company at the table, which included Nils Ivar Agøy, Måns Björkman (Nils Ivar and Måns added August 30^th — my apologies for forgetting them at first), Beregond (from Forodrim, the Stockholm Tolkien Society), Christopher Kreuzer, Allan Turner, Janet Brennan Croft, and the brothers Johan and Håkan Olin. For anyone who had previously been to events in the Tolkien Society the Standing Silence and the toasts to the Professor and to absent friends were of course expected and familiar as old friends, but though one has read about it, it is a different matter to actually be there and be a part of it. Rituals have the function of tying people together, of strengthening the sense of unity and common purpose and interests, and this sense of community is, at least for me, a very valuable addition to being a Tolkien enthusiast. As the food disappeared from plates and tables, the social aspect of course became more and more prominent. A number of participants went to the Q&A session with a couple of the people behind The Fellows Hip — a film celebrating gamer culture and The Lord of the Rings, while others chose to continue the socializing outside where the temperature was approaching comfortable levels (at least as perceived by this Dane).

Monday — the last day.

Already from the morning there was a certain degree of closure and breaking up in the air. Over breakfast I finally got around to hear Andrew Higgins about his current work (he is working on a Ph.D. with Dmitra Fimi while at the same time doing his day-time job — impressive!) but in the various breakfast conversations one could also hear the consciousness of there being only a few hours until we would spread to all the corners of the world.

After breakfast I managed to nearly finish my packing before the first session, which was a panel called ‘Lifelong Learning Tolkien: Face-to-face and Online’ with Corey Olsen as chair, and Shaun Gunner (of the Tolkien Society and the Tolkien Gateway), Mick Ennis (of the Ironville & Codnor School Myth & Magic Reading & Language Group), Dimitra Fimi (of Cardiff Metropolitan University), and Christine Ahmed (LotR and the Scottish border). Corey Olsen's pages as the Tolkien Professor and his Mythgard Institute are (I hope) well-known, as is Dmitra Fimi's work (which also includes on-line Tolkien classes), and the Tolkien Gateway. Mick Ennis' story about the school-children and their travels moved me strongly — this group offers these kids a chance to grow and develop in so many ways; not just intellectually, but also socially, emotionally and in other ways. It's really amazing! Another highlight was the look on Shaun Gunner's face when he asked how many present had accounts on the Tolkien Gateway, and even Dmitra Fimi raised her hand . . . priceless! Overall the panel was good with its focus on the many ways to learn more about Tolkien that is available, but also with the ever-present warning to not trust the internet inherently: check up on everything if you can.

For the last session, I chose to go to a final session on ‘Tolkien's sources’. Andrew Morton started with a promise of explaining ‘Everything you need to know about the real Bag End’ — and then some. The presentation included a number of pictures of the real Bag End, where Tolkien's maternal aunt, Jane Neave, had lived and farmed. Tolkien is known to have visited the farm only twice: on reconvalescence in 1923 and later on with the whole family. The presentation contained a lot of visual evidence, without which a summary will merely appear bland. However, the pictures and related discussions spiced with a lot of interesting bits of information about his old house (a settlement at this place goes back to before the Norman period), and the family (including Jane and Mabel's father, John Suffield, and his love for his daughter's farm), made the talk quite interesting to follow.

The final bit of scholarly work that I got to enjoy at the conference was Dmitra Fimi's presentation on ‘Elves, Goblins and Other ‘Fairy’ Things in The Hobbit: Tolkien’s Victorian and Edwardian Inspiration’. This again relied on visual evidence — mainly Victorian images of faries, and discussed how Tolkien had relied on some of these Victorian faries, though the very petite creatures with wings that he came to resent so strongly, and how their influence can be traced quite a lot longer than I had previously thought: even after Tolkien had renounced them so strongly in his essay ‘On Fairy-Stories.’

After this, all that was left of this fantastic conference was the closing ceremony. Allowing us a last opportunity for cheering, this included some additional award-giving. First Nancy Martsch presented the Beyond Bree awards that are given ‘in recognition of outstanding contribution to the study of JRR Tolkien, from the Readers of Beyond Bree’. Unlike previous award votes, the readers had this time voted for a single clear winner, Mark Hooker. Honourary mentions went to Dinah Hazel (The Plants of Middle-earth: Botany and Sub-creation) and Phil Goss (the Compleat Gyde to Tolkien Calendars). Congratulations to all — the awards are well-deserved!

Finally the chair of the conference, Lynn Whitaker, took the stand for the closing words. All the people who had helped make the conference were duly thanked (including the participants), and of course the committee. In the middle of this, the chair of the Tolkien Society, Sally Kennett, had to take over in order to present the society's Gold Badge to the conference's booking's officer, Lyn Wilshire, after which she proceeded to present one also to the chair, Lynn Whitaker. When the cheering had finally subseded, that was it — the Return of the Ring was over, and all that remained was to check out of our rooms and go back each to our own corner of this middle-earth.

Additional thoughts

Weapens of la Compagnie du Dragon Vert
Photo: Lindon

Live re-enactment by la
Compagnie du Dragon Vert
Photo: Lindon

Writing in this diary-like form obviously skips over some things. Where, for instance, would I put something about la Compagnie du Dragon Vert (The Fellowship of the Green Dragon) — the French re-enactment group whose camp I passed several times per day and from whom I bought a Gondorian penny (or whatever the name of the Gondorian coin may be)?  Yet their presence was certainly very important to the atmosphere of the conference as a whole, and I enjoyed looking at their camp very much.

And what about the meals? Which day was it that a fortunate lack of space at other tables landed me in a very interesting conversation with Ben Barootes? I can't remember, but it was a very pleasant dinner. The same questions can be asked about other conversations — I also had a very interesting talk with Merlin DeTardo over a meal one day, but these things tend to blur a little and unless they're in the programme, I lose track of which day it was (I did keep copious notes from all the lectures, presentations, talks, lectures and panels that I went to, but for some reason I forgot to do the same for my meals — something I should perhaps remember next time . . . whenever that may be. 

Taking notes. I may not be looking intently at the speaker
(David Doughan), but that is because I am busy taking
notes in my book.
Photo: Andrew Wells

One of the points that Lynn Whitaker, the chair of the Return of the Ring, made at the closing ceremony was that it had been an aim of the conference to combine, put together and not least break down perceived barriers between fandom, entertainment and academia — a goal that I find that the Return of the Ring fulfilled, even to top marks! I never once perceived any kind of barriers, but rather often experienced people crossing freely where such barriers should have been, had they ever been erected. 

What is left to say? I am deeply grateful for the opportunity to come to this conference (in particular to my family for putting up with it — they are not Tolkien enthusiasts). Also I am grateful for the friendship that I've been shown both from people that I had met on-line before the conference and from new people, and I have been dumbfounded at the kind words about my presentation and what other things I've done in Mallorn and here. When we get right down to it, this is what is the true purpose of going to conferences like this: to meet people and connect in our shared love for professor Tolkien's work. 

The Professor!